Bad art is not a crime
Roger Waters sucks but, no, he wasn't "glorifying" the Nazis in his Berlin show.
Stop me if you’ve heard this before: an unhinged public figure goes out of his way to offend normies through obnoxious, ahistorical performative activism, whines about how he’s being persecuted because of the inevitable backlash, and contrarian par excellence Matt Taibbi jumps in to defend him.
That’s the dog-bites-man part of the story. The man-bites-dog part? Taibbi is right.
Well, partly right, at least. I think he gives this old drunk way more credit than he deserves for his art, such as it is. As far as I know, the paywalled section could argue that dressing up as a Nazi in Berlin1 while comparing Anne Frank to the Palestinians is good and also The Wall movie is watchable while sober.
And I long ago stopped giving Waters any benefit of the doubt about whether he’s just an “anti-Zionist” opposed to Israel’s policies alongside his strident opposition to the actions of aggressive dictatorships. Because that opposition does not exist.
But you can be an antisemite without being an actual Nazi . Hatred of the Jews, unfortunately, is a virus with many different mutations, and the Venn Diagram between the “punch Nazis” crowd and the “death to Israel” crowd has a surprising (and depressing) amount of overlap.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Rigid Thinking to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.