Breaking news: politicians are hypocrites
Which doesn't mean the "Twitter files" writers are, though.
You might want to sit down for a moment and brace yourself. But - are you ready? - Republicans who went all-in on the Twitter files and denounced Democrats' attempted censorship of opinions they didn't like...also, it turns out, had their people contact Twitter to demand censorship of opinions they didn't like.
I know right?!?
WHEN THE WHITE House called up Twitter in the early morning hours of September 9, 2019, officials had what they believed was a serious issue to report: Famous model Chrissy Teigen had just called President Donald Trump “a pussy ass bitch” on Twitter — and the White House wanted the tweet to come down.
That exchange — revealed during Wednesday’s House Oversight Committee hearing on Twitter by Rep. Gerry Connolly — and others like it are nowhere to be found in Elon Musk’s “Twitter Files” releases, which have focused almost exclusively on requests from Democrats and the feds to the social media company. The newly empowered Republican majority in the House of Representatives is now devoting significant resources and time to investigating this supposed “collusion” between liberal politicians and Twitter. Some Republicans even believe the release of the “Twitter Files” is the “tip of the spear” of their crusade against the alleged liberal bias of Big Tech.
But former Trump administration officials and Twitter employees tell Rolling Stone that the White House’s Teigen tweet demand was hardly an isolated incident: The Trump administration and its allied Republicans in Congress routinely asked Twitter to take down posts they objected to — the exact behavior that they’re claiming makes President Biden, the Democrats, and Twitter complicit in an anti-free speech conspiracy to muzzle conservatives online.
“It was strange to me when all of these investigations were announced because it was all about the exact same stuff that we had done [when Donald Trump was in office],” one former top aide to a senior Trump administration official tells Rolling Stone. “It was normal.”
In interviews with former Twitter personnel, onetime Trump administration officials, and other people familiar with the matter, each source recalled what could be described as a “hotline,” “tipline,” or large Twitter “database” of moderation and removal requests that was frequently pinged by the offices of powerful Democrats and Republicans alike.
Matt Taibbi used to work for Rolling Stone, so many people are crowing about his old publication showing his blatant hypocrisy.
Except, well, he did in fact mention this in his initial Twitter files Tweetstorm:
Most of the journalists Elon Musk hand picked for the Twitter Files deserve some legitimate criticism (well, except for Alex Berenson, who deserves nothing but legitimate criticism) but I often wonder how much of the actual reporting their critics actually bothered reading.
My opinion about the "Twitter Files"? They raise some serious questions about officials trying to influence content on a private social media platform, but many of the claims are seriously overblown.
...which is kind of fitting for Twitter, honestly. (Also, posting them as interminable Twitter threads made them pretty much unreadable, but that’s another post. Maybe that’s part of the reason their critics never actually read them, come to think of it.)
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Rigid Thinking to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.